Yes. Send outreach to candidates and companies who don't know you from a separate email domain, and keep your main domain for clients and candidates already in process. Gmail tracks spam complaints and volume per domain: if cold messages get reported from your main address, the emails to your clients start landing in spam too.
Why your main domain is the one at risk
When you write to people who don't know you, some of them will hit "Report spam". That's normal for outreach, even when the message is good and personal. The problem is where that report lands.
Google says it plainly in its sender guidelines: Gmail tracks volume, feedback and limits per domain and per IP address. Your domain builds a reputation, and every message from it, to anyone, carries that reputation. So the reports a cold campaign collects don't stay in the campaign. They follow the invoice you send a client the next morning.
For an agency, the main domain is the business: client threads, offers, interview invitations, the candidate who's about to sign. None of that should depend on how a cold sequence did this week.
The numbers Gmail and Yahoo look at
Yahoo sets the same line: keep your spam rate below 0.3%. Both ask every sender to authenticate with SPF or DKIM at a minimum, and both apply stricter rules to bulk senders.
Google defines a bulk sender as anyone sending close to 5,000 messages or more to personal Gmail accounts in 24 hours, and two details matter for an agency:
| Rule | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Messages from the same primary domain count together | A subdomain like outreach.youragency.com adds to youragency.com. It doesn't start a separate count |
| Once a bulk sender, always a bulk sender | Google says the status doesn't expire, even if you later send less |
| Enforcement tightened in November 2025 | Google's FAQ says non-compliant mail now sees temporary and permanent rejections |
A recruiter writing 50 messages a day won't reach 5,000, even though a specialized search needs 100 or more. But the spam rate is a percentage, not a volume: 50 cold messages a day with three reports is already well over 0.3%.
A separate email domain, not a subdomain
A subdomain looks like the tidy answer, and it does help you watch each kind of mail on its own. But by Google's own counting, mail from outreach.youragency.com counts toward youragency.com, and Google doesn't promise to keep their reputations apart. A separate domain does.
Pick one that's obviously yours, so the person reading recognizes the agency:
| Main domain | Outreach domain |
|---|---|
| youragency.com | hello-youragency.com · youragency.co · tryyouragency.com |
Then set it up like a real inbox, because it is one:
- Authenticate it. SPF, DKIM and DMARC, the same as your main domain. Your email provider walks you through it in its DNS settings.
- Make it reply. It's a real inbox with a real person behind it. A reply to an outreach email has to reach you.
- Point the website to yours. If someone types the outreach domain into a browser, it should take them to your agency's site.
- Use your real name. The same sender, the same signature, the same agency. A separate domain isn't a disguise.
How to warm up a new domain
A domain created yesterday has no history, and Google says to start with a low volume to engaged people and increase it slowly, without sudden spikes. In practice:
| Week | New messages per day, per inbox |
|---|---|
| 1 | 10 to 20 |
| 2 | 20 to 35 |
| 3 onwards | Up to around 50, if replies are coming in and nobody's reporting |
Write first to people likely to answer: candidates you've talked to before, warm contacts. Replies tell Gmail people want your mail. And keep the messages personal, which is also what gets replies: how to write to someone who isn't looking is in our post on the passive candidate.
Frequently asked questions
Should recruiters use a separate domain for cold email?
Yes. Gmail and Yahoo track spam reports per domain. Sending cold outreach from a separate domain keeps those reports away from the domain you use with clients and candidates in process.
Is a subdomain enough for outreach?
Not to protect your main domain. Google counts messages from a subdomain toward its primary domain, so a separate domain is the safer choice.
What spam rate does Gmail allow?
Google recommends keeping the spam rate reported in Postmaster Tools under 0.1% and never reaching 0.3%. Yahoo also asks senders to stay below 0.3%.
How many cold emails can I send per day from one inbox?
Start a new domain at 10 to 20 a day and ramp up over two or three weeks, to around 50 per inbox. More inboxes, not more volume per inbox, is how you grow.
How long does it take to warm up a new email domain?
Two to three weeks of gradual volume, writing first to people likely to reply. Google asks senders to increase volume slowly and avoid sudden spikes.
Where Reclee comes in
In Reclee you connect more than one Gmail: your usual one for clients and the outreach one. When you connect an inbox, Reclee recommends a separate domain, and each inbox has its own daily limit, 50 by default, that you set between 10 and 150. You can reserve part of it for candidates, so prospecting for clients never takes the day's candidate messages. Every reply lands in the same place, whichever inbox it came to. You can start free.